Finding the right insurance shouldn’t mean calling multiple agencies, comparing endless quotes, and trying to figure out which coverage is actually right for you.
As an independent insurance agency, we work with a selection of highly rated insurance carriers, giving you access to multiple options in one place. Instead of getting locked into a single company’s products, we shop the market for coverage that fits your needs, your budget, and your situation.”
Whether you’re looking to insure your home, auto, business, or more, we can compare options from different carriers so you don’t have to do the legwork yourself.
” Insurance isn’t one-size-fits-all. That’s why we don’t believe you should be limited to a single company’s rates or coverage options.
Our job is to do the shopping for you. Your job is simply to choose the option that feels right.
Let us help you compare your options and find coverage that works for you. “
At Allegiance First Insurance Services, we believe insurance is about more than policies. It’s about protecting the people, homes, businesses, and dreams that matter most.
As an independent insurance agency, we proudly serve individuals, families, and business owners with a full range of insurance solutions, including Auto, Home, Renters, Commercial, Business Owners Policies, Workers’ Compensation, Recreational Vehicles, Life Insurance, Annuities, Indexed Universal Life, Long-Term Care, and more.
With decades of combined industry experience, our mission is simple: provide honest guidance, personalized service, and insurance solutions that fit your unique needs. We believe every client deserves to understand their coverage, feel confident in their decisions, and have a trusted advisor they can call whenever life changes.
Rather than simply selling insurance, we take the time to perform a comprehensive insurance review. By understanding your goals, assets, and potential risks, we can recommend the right combination of coverage to help protect your financial future while keeping your premiums as competitive as possible.
Because we partner with many of the nation’s top A-rated insurance companies, you have the power of choice. Instead of being limited to one carrier, we compare multiple options to find the coverage that best fits your needs and budget.
Education is also a cornerstone of our agency. We believe informed clients make better decisions, which is why we take the time to explain insurance and financial concepts in clear, straightforward language. Whether you’re protecting your first home, growing a business, planning for retirement, or preparing for your family’s future, we’re here to help you make confident decisions every step of the way.
At Allegiance First Insurance Services, our goal is to build lasting relationships. Not just write policies. We want to be the team you trust through every stage of life, providing guidance, support, and peace of mind for years to come.
We invite you to schedule a complimentary insurance review and discover how personalized advice and the right coverage can help protect everything you’ve worked so hard to build.
Allegiance First Insurance Services was founded by Amber Warner and Amanda Brennen with one goal: to provide honest advice, exceptional service, and personalized insurance solutions that put people before policies. We believe every client deserves an insurance team they can trust. Not just at renewal time, but through every stage of life.
As Co-Owner of Allegiance First Insurance Services, Amber Warner has dedicated more than 25 years to helping individuals, families, and business owners protect what matters most. Alongside her business partner, Amanda Brennen, she co-founded Allegiance First with a shared vision of creating an agency where relationships come first, clients receive honest guidance, and every recommendation is made with their best interests in mind.
Amber is passionate about educating clients so they understand their coverage and feel confident in the decisions they make. She believes insurance is about much more than policies. It’s about protecting families, businesses, and the future people have worked so hard to build. Her goal is to make the insurance process simple, personal, and stress-free while providing exceptional service every step of the way.
Outside the office, Amber enjoys spending quality time with her family, and creating lasting memories with the people she loves. She understands firsthand how important it is to protect what matters most and considers it a privilege to help clients do the same every day.
As Co-Owner of Allegiance First Insurance Services, Amanda Brennen is passionate about helping clients navigate their insurance decisions with confidence. She believes every client deserves personalized guidance, honest advice, and an insurance professional who truly listens and understands their unique needs.
Amanda enjoys helping individuals, families, and business owners find insurance solutions that provide peace of mind while delivering the exceptional service every client deserves. She is committed to building lasting relationships through clear communication, attention to detail, and a genuine desire to help others protect what matters most.
Outside the office, Amanda values family above all else. Whether she’s enjoying a relaxing weekend, celebrating life’s special moments, or simply spending time with the people she loves, she knows those moments are what make life meaningful. That appreciation for family is one of the reasons she is so passionate about helping others protect the people, homes, businesses, and futures they cherish most.
